7 May 2021
1300 794 893

Choose your poison: stamp duty or land tax?

Peter Switzer
18 November 2020

Generally a state budget is about as interesting as a documentary on the breeding habits of snails but the New South Wales Treasurer, Dominic Perrottet has given his potential property buyers a Dirty Harry question on something that costs the average homebuyer $26,000.

Dom is giving property purchasers the option to pay stamp duty when they buy a home or pay an annual, smaller land tax. But of course, the longer you stay in a property, the more you’d pay. And then you have to hope that the tax rate won’t be tweaked upwards by future Treasurers.

This leads to that famous Harry Callahan question that future property buyers in NSW will have to ask and answer, which goes like this “You've got to ask yourself one question: ‘Do I feel lucky?’ Well, do ya, punk?”

And political experts say that this NSW move could easily encourage other states to follow suit, with both NSW and Victoria collecting about 25% of their total annual revenue from stamp duty.

In NSW, the average stamp duty slug is $26,000. Of course, this increases the more expensive the property you buy is. And SMH’s Shane Wright says there are 200,000 transactions that attract this slug on homebuyers, and in a good year it can bring in $9 billion.

But why would a Treasurer want to swap stamp duty for a land tax? Here are a few reasons:

  • It would steady the tax revenue received each year and wouldn’t collapse during a recession or house price collapse.
  • It will encourage downsizers to sell their too big home and buy something smaller, freeing up these bigger homes for families.
  • Potentially, more revenue would be collected over time.
  • It could increase the interest in first homebuyers and others to buy into property.
  • It could encourage more building of new homes, which brings more economic activity.

Wright points to the fact that the ACT is already doing it, albeit in a slightly different way. And “an independent review by a Victoria University study this year found the tax mix switch had driven a real increase in economic growth, investment, private consumption and wages across the ACT.”

The innovation means buying a $500,000 property in Canberra will have a stamp duty slug of $11,400, while in NSW it would be $17,900 and $21,970 in Victoria.

Economists say the shift to a land tax means an inefficient, inequitable tax that distorts market activity and discourages people from moving and even buying is removed for a better tax.

The Real Estate Institute of NSW supports the idea but does ask a question that is a fair one to ask: “A land tax may be more broadly-based than stamp duty, but it still only applies to property. Investors in shares, for instance, pay no comparable tax,” said the CEO of the REINSW, Tim McKibbin.

The Treasurer thinks young property buyers will tick the box on a lower upfront land tax calling it “the Netflix of property tax," while bagging stamp duty as “a tax from a bygone era.”

The ABC says: “It will require every other state to follow suit and hefty compensation from the Federal Government during the next few years. Politically, that's a tough sell.”

Ultimately, the devil will be in the detail on this initiative but just as we were warned in ancient mythology that we should “beware of Greeks bearing gifts”, modern day advisers might warn to beware of politicians bearing tax gifts. What can look good in the short run could prove costly in the long run. And I wonder how Dirty Harry would decide to answer Treasurer Perrottet’s taxing question?

Click here to subscribe to the Switzer TV channel on YouTube and keep up to date with all of our shows.

Subscribe to our Switzer Daily newsletter and get our latest articles, videos and podcasts straight to your inbox!

Get the latest financial, business, and political expert commentary delivered to your inbox.

When you sign up, we will never give away or sell or barter or trade your email address.

And you can unsubscribe at any time!
1300 794 893
© 2006-2021 Switzer. All Rights Reserved. Australian Financial Services Licence Number 286531. 
homeshopping-cartphoneenvelopedollargraduation-cap linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram