Home › Feature Daily › No guts, no glory: why won’t the PM and Treasurer let anyone check their spending?

No guts, no glory: why won’t the PM and Treasurer let anyone check their spending?

Inflation is stuck at 4.3% and the RBA looks set to spoil Cup Day with another rate rise. There’s one cause of our inflation problem that Canberra can actually control, so why won’t Chalmers let anyone take a proper look at it?

The Albanese Government is being pressured to have a special audit into its spending as more and more economic experts argue that Treasurer Chalmers needs to reduce the outlays that are adding to our inflation rate now sitting at 4.3%. This stubbornly high inflation is set to make the Reserve Bank raise the cash rate by 0.25% to 4.85% on Tuesday’s Cup Day.

If we don’t see a rate rise at 2.30pm on that day, that will be the best win for the country’s borrowers they will ever see on the first Tuesday in November!

Free Daily Newsletter

Never miss an expert insight

Join over 100,000 Australians who get Peter Switzer’s top finance stories delivered free every weekday.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

The Australian reports that with government spending at a 40-year high, if you leave the exceptional circumstances of the pandemic lockdown out, a proper look at the Treasurer’s and state treasurers’ spending needs to be reviewed to see where cuts could be made to help bring inflation down.

Treasurer Chalmers and Prime Minister Albanese keep denying the role of spending in our high and sticky inflation but no one with economic training will support their argument.

Our inflation is caused by:

  1. High government spending that pumps up income and demand, which adds to price pressures.
  2. The oil price spike due to the Trump-Iran war.
  3. The imported inflation from high global oil and power prices that bleed into the costs of imported products.
  4. The RBA’s interest rate rises not only hit demand to lower inflation, but in the short term they raise costs and many businesses pass on the costs. Landlords are cases in point, who raise rents when their borrowing costs rise.
  5. Big businesses with market power, such as Telstra, can raise prices as the cost of borrowing rises and that’s inflationary as well.
  6. The country’s productivity, which cuts costs and lowers inflation, is at an historical low.

The sensible argument for the Treasurer to accept should be that the RBA has to do its job and we can’t control Donald Trump and the Iranian leadership, who block the Strait of Hormuz, which drives up oil prices but we can control the Albanese Government’s spending.

In fact, if the Treasurer cut spending, that would reduce the need for the RBA to raise interest rates, which would reduce the cost-push effects of higher interest rates feeding into higher prices, rents, etc.

In 2014, the Coalition Government had a federal commission of audit where Robert Fisher, who was a key public servant on the body and was a former head of state departments such as welfare under both Labor and Liberal governments, told The Australian he would support a new official probe into government spending.

Right now, both the Treasurer and PM are deflecting criticisms and calls for spending cuts, with Mr Albanese railing against the likes of former Liberal prime minister John Howard and his treasurer Peter Costello, over their warnings on spending and tax. He slammed them as “partisan political players”.

But he can’t use these insults on union heavyweights, like former ACTU boss Bill Kelty, former Reserve Bank governors, ex-Treasury secretaries, prominent business leaders, independent economists and even NSW Premier Chris Minns.

In the 1980s, the Treasurer’s pin-up boy, mentor and former treasurer, as well as prime minister, Paul Keating, went hard on spending cuts, supported by then-Finance Minister Peter Walsh.

These guys cut spending, which put them offside with their government colleagues but they had guts, unlike the current crop of political pygmies who play politics much better than economics.

And it shows, with unemployment up from 4.1% to 4.7% this year and interest rates up four times, with another one highly likely next Tuesday.

Of course, taking steps to improve the country’s productivity by reducing stifling regulation would also help but these could have negative political implications for a government that has helped make Pauline Hanson and One Nation a popular alternative in opinion polls.

It will take mature political leadership and enlightened policy decisions to bring inflation down, but this all requires courage and leadership.

As the old saying goes: “No guts, no glory!”

Sometimes accepting the hard-to-swallow advice from respected advice-givers is a sign of wise maturity, which at the moment looks scarce on the ground in Canberra.

Peter Switzer

Peter Switzer

Peter Switzer is the founder of Switzer Group - a content, publishing and financial services firm. Peter is an award-winning broadcaster, talking each morning to 2GB's Ben Fordham about the latest in finance and money. You can read his views daily on Switzer.com.au, and subscribe to Switzer Report for his latest insights, analysis and recommendations.

View all articles by Peter Switzer →

More from Peter Switzer

4 comments on “No guts, no glory: why won’t the PM and Treasurer let anyone check their spending?”

  1. Harry Volting

    It’s probably too late. We have over the last 30 years or so, embedded expectations of Government Handouts. I’d love to see a comprehensive table of the multitude of government benefits available to our residents. I’m sure many would shock those that remain self supporting AND highly taxed.

    If we do head into recession, will our government again pump money into the system making matters even worse from a government debt perspective! I think all the shots have been fired already so there is no wriggle room left.

    Reply
  2. Michael Lee

    No guts, no backbone, very little mental ability and certainly no respect for Australia… Australians.
    The worst ‘Government’ on record and we can do nothing to change the situation.
    Governor General not exercising her authority…all very demoralising.

    Reply
  3. RICHARD ASHTON

    “ Leadership?”

    Albo and the good Doctor cannot understand words exceeding 4 letters.. bar “votes!”

    Reply
  4. Sue

    It takes people (commentators) with long memories to be able to call out the self-serving Governments we have had recently. What a pity that Australian economic history is not a mandatory subject in secondary school.
    We can’t expect a brighter future when we simply swamp our young people with self-serving ideologies that don’t address the broader social and political landscape.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *