Home › Feature Daily › Fair Work tells small business: suck it up, princess

Fair Work tells small business: suck it up, princess

Employers of white-collar workers have been put under pressure to say yes to employees who want to work from home (WFH). This follows the employment umpire showing small business employers the door, despite requesting a six-month delay to giving workers a right to deliver their services from home.

The Council of Small Business Organisations (COSBOA), a group representing the biggest number of small businesses in Australia, asked for a stay of execution for six months because, as The Australian reports, “small businesses relied on payroll and workforce software providers, bookkeepers and advisers to translate award changes into practice.”

As you’d expect, the full bench of the Fair Work Commission rejected the request arguing that “the changes did not impose any compliance burden on non-consenting employers because they only operated on a consensual basis”.

Free Daily Newsletter

Never miss an expert insight

Join over 100,000 Australians who get Peter Switzer’s top finance stories delivered free every weekday.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

And this is an important issue because this right to work-from-home decision only applies to situations where an employee and employer agree to a WFH arrangement.

The Australian reports: “This means hundreds of thousands of clerical workers will be able to start accessing landmark award rights to request to work from home from next week, after the [commission] rejected a bid by the small business lobby to delay the changes by six months.”

This decision by the FWC tells a small business owner with employees, business debts, rising interest rates, tax obligations and a slowing economy, that they’re now under pressure to say yes to an employee who wants to work from home.

The WFH ruling says it applies where there is a consensus that the employer agrees to a request to work from home, but why should an employer be put into a difficult situation, where saying no could result in an employee looking for another job?

Objectively, it’s great if a win-win situation results when an employer grants an employee the chance to work from home. It can be great for the family of the worker and if productivity of the employee isn’t affected, then it’s a plus all round.

However, Reserve Bank of Australia Governor Michele Bullock keeps telling us that we have a productivity problem that partly explains our sticky inflation and rising interest rates. And so I wonder if the workplace legal experts on the FWC even gave productivity a thought when it effectively told small business employers to “suck it up princess!”

Recently, Ms Bullock’s Assistant Governor and chief economist, Sarah Hunter gave a speech underlining the need for us to raise productivity. “As productivity rises it becomes cheaper to produce goods and services, and the economic pie grows as we can produce more with the scarce resources we have,” she explained. “In the data that economists track, this improvement shows up as an increase in real incomes, which is a dollar value of the goods and services we can buy per hour worked, after stripping out inflation. For example, in 1901 it took 18 minutes on average to earn enough to buy a loaf of bread. Today that average is just 4 minutes.”

This chart shows how productivity delivers more real income per hour for Australians and graphically shows why we should be making decisions that improve this key driver of economic success, both production- and income-wise.

This FWC decision does look fair for the hundreds of thousands of clerical workers who now can ask, with more clout, for permission to work from home. Sure, the strong-minded boss who really wants their worker in the office, might simply say no to a request but others who aren’t as confident or who might fear losing a worker, having to recruit again and pay for the ‘privilege’ might simply give in, hoping the business won’t be negatively affected.

So, from October 26, employees will be able to ask with more confidence to work from home knowing that their award working conditions cover any consensus agreement between them and their bosses.

It’s a win for the employee but the jury is out on whether employers should be celebrating the greater pressure on them to agree to an employee working from home.

To be upfront, business groups have accepted this WFH desire of employees but it doesn’t mean that in a perfect world they want it. But this FWC decision does show how pathetic the Victorian Government’s proposed mandated WFH right law is.

This country has a productivity problem and I have to wonder if it’s linked to the myriad of federal and state government decisions that have taken away many of the leadership rights of an employer, to create a more attractive working life for employees.

In sport, we do say, nice guys run last and I think the same applies in business. We’ve gone soft and it shows in our productivity. And the price is high inflation, rising interest rates, slower economic growth and higher unemployment.

Peter Switzer

Peter Switzer

Peter Switzer is the founder of Switzer Group - a content, publishing and financial services firm. Peter is an award-winning broadcaster, talking each morning to 2GB's Ben Fordham about the latest in finance and money. You can read his views daily on Switzer.com.au, and subscribe to Switzer Report for his latest insights, analysis and recommendations.

View all articles by Peter Switzer →

More from Peter Switzer

7 comments on “Fair Work tells small business: suck it up, princess”

  1. Harry Volting

    Wow! Gone are the days where the person paying the wages provided the “place of employment”. Pretty soon, there will be issues relating to isolation as we all become housebound. Home delivery of everything and only leaving the house for the next tattoo or lip embellishment!

    Reply
    1. Mei

      The delivery people can’t work from home!

      Reply
  2. RICHARD ASHTON

    The “fools” in this country are small business operators. Why would anyone with enterprise and a dream bother ?
    The FWC decision and its insistence on immediate compliance will be the final nail in the coffin for many of these under recognised battlers.
    RIP Australia

    Reply
  3. Sue

    Well, this is going to slow the economy down. The ‘recession we had to have’?

    Reply
  4. Ray Goldsmith

    Work from home may turn into work from Mumbai. Employees need to look at the bigger picture.

    Reply
  5. Stephen smith

    Great comments herein.

    All I can say is that once recession does come, the FWC may also be on the unemployment line.

    We cannot as a country, continue on the sane direction , towards a murky end!

    Reply
  6. Tony Fatouros

    Working from home weakens industries by limiting staff interaction, which is how employees learn from colleagues who have already solved the same problems.
    Remote work reduces the in-person interaction that lets experienced staff train newer employees through real, day-to-day problems

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *