Home › Feature Daily › David Jones on death row. What shoppers need to know.

David Jones on death row. What shoppers need to know.

With landlords refusing to bankroll a restructure, the 188-year-old retailer looks headed for voluntary administration. Here’s what it means for your gift cards, loyalty points, refunds and those Christmas bargains.

After 188 years of trading, legendary retailers David Jones could be set to be a victim of the kind of end-of-year fire sale it had for its wide range of consumer and luxury goods. But this time it won’t be the owner of DJs doing the selling. It will be an insolvency expert or receivers!

It looks like the retailer will go into a voluntary administration (VA) but after trying to hold back on rent payments, the landlords have called their bluff.

Free Daily Newsletter

Never miss an expert insight

Join over 100,000 Australians who get Peter Switzer’s top finance stories delivered free every weekday.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Those landlords include names that include such as Westfields and Scentre Group, have told DJ’s owner, Anchorage Capital, that they want their money, which Anchorage wanted to use from its October rents so David Jones could pay staff and suppliers and fund a restructure.

It was also negotiating access to about $70m in bank guarantees used as bonds that are tied to its shopping centre leases.

However, in both cases, the people who needed to say yes said NO!

So, today, we should see DJs go into VA, which won’t be good news for staff and creditors, including big brand suppliers of the consumer goods we all buy as we move into Christmas.

We know a lot of staff might get to keep their jobs ahead of the pre- and post-Christmas sales, but what does it mean for the insolvency people who will have the job to keep the business going until either a buyer of the business comes along or all assets are sold.

What about DJ’s customers? Here are some issues customers of the store should know:

  1. Spend DJs gift cards ASAP before a receiver changes the rules.
  2. Gift card holders are unsecured creditors to DJs with no real power when a VA is called.
  3. While loyalty points holders are likely to be losers as well, the extent of the loss is unclear.
  4. When Barbeques Galore went into VA, it honoured gift cards, but it demanded another purchase of equivalent value.
  5. If you have an exchange or refund in the wings, move now, because you have rights, but it could take a long time to have the matter settle and it might not be as good as you’d like!
  6. Stores should stay open at least over the end-of-year sales but after that, lots of store closures and a new owner of its flagship stores in places such as Sydney and Melbourne is bound to keep these open.
  7. There could be huge Christmas shopping discounts as the VA team will be looking for cash to pay back creditors as best they can.

While this is a sad chapter for our iconic store, it has been the fate of some of the biggest name department stores in the world.

Reuters revealed some of these famous stores filing for bankruptcy over the past six years include Saks, Lord & Taylor, Neiman Marcus, Barneys, Sears, Bed Bath & Beyond, Toys ‘R’ Us and the UK’s Harvey Nichols. And even London’s Selfridges needed saving when its owner Signa was declared insolvent.

Covid and online shopping have KO’d department stores but so has the arrival of category killers such as Rebel Sport, fast fashion giants such as H&M and Zara, diversifying retailers such as Kmart, the whole online consumer world and the arrival of new generations of shoppers in a media-diverse world. All these factors have made the department store a virtual retail dinosaur on death row.

I think the name David Jones will survive but it will be sold for a lot less than what the former South African owner, Woolworths, paid in 2014: $2.1 billion.

And it will be less than the $100 million Anchorage paid in 2022, though Woolworths sold off its properties, so Anchorage largely bought the business called David Jones.

And that business isn’t likely to be worth $100 million in any future fire sale, especially in the economy that has emerged under the current Federal Government and Reserve Bank!

Peter Switzer

Peter Switzer

Peter Switzer is the founder of Switzer Group - a content, publishing and financial services firm. Peter is an award-winning broadcaster, talking each morning to 2GB's Ben Fordham about the latest in finance and money. You can read his views daily on Switzer.com.au, and subscribe to Switzer Report for his latest insights, analysis and recommendations.

View all articles by Peter Switzer →

More from Peter Switzer

5 comments on “David Jones on death row. What shoppers need to know.”

  1. Stephen smith

    Pete, at time of writing, DJs had a VA appointed.

    Let’s just hope someone with deep pockets will refi their debt into equity and provide some CF relief to get their rents up today

    A very sad day indeed.

    Cheers

    Reply
  2. Harry Volting

    I remember I went into their Sydney 10 years ago and was shocked at the complete absence of staff to provide service to the few customers in there. The writing was on the wall then, with online and more nimble retailers stealing business from David Jones and other bricks and mortar department stores.

    And remember Gowings went the same way.

    There was probably a smaller market for full service, department stores, but with no staff insight to provide “full service”, the death spiral was inevitable!

    Maybe an opportunity for Myer to smell the roses and market itself as a proper, full service department store. It is really its only potential point of differentiation! Last time I was in Myer it also required a search party to find a staff member for assistance!

    Reply
  3. Harry Volting

    And that’s why I never buy or give “gift cards”. Cash is king!

    Reply
  4. John

    The David Jones closing is a beacon of the damage being done to the people by the socialists in Canberra.
    We have seen thousands of small businesses closing and now a major retailer as the middle class is hollowed out by the cost of living and no longer has money to spend

    Reply
  5. Frank Gilsenan

    Hopefully the DJ’s brand can be saved by a new owner? It would be sad for many loyal customers to see this iconic retailer disappear. As I mentioned in a previous post the only way forward is to shutter all non performing stores especially in Westfield centres where rents are high. Keep one high end themed flagship store in Sydney & Melbourne CBD ??

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *