Home › Feature Daily › Chalmers asked where he should cut spending, and Australia’s top CEOs told him!

Chalmers asked where he should cut spending, and Australia’s top CEOs told him!

The country’s top business leaders were always going to jump in and show Treasurer Chalmers how to suck eggs, when he weirdly challenged his critics to show him where he should cut spending. Remember most economists cite the Albanese Government’s big spending as a prime cause of our too-high inflation rate.

It’s not the only cause, with the impact of the Iran and Ukraine wars adding to global costs of key inputs into what we make and the demands of the AI boom too adding to inflation.

But remember, the RBA will let us have inflation in the 2-3% band, and it could be argued that our 4% inflation might be in the band with a less big spending government in Canberra.

Free Daily Newsletter

Never miss an expert insight

Join over 100,000 Australians who get Peter Switzer’s top finance stories delivered free every weekday.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

So, what have our top business bosses told Jim to cut? The Australian has revealed the following:

Gerry Harvey: Cut regulation to reduce the cost of doing business and the size of the public service.

Andre Reich (ex-CEO of The Reject Shop): Agreed, arguing low-income Australians suffer when governments overspend. He cites how the Greek economy has U-turned after its government stopped overspending and created budget surpluses.

Graham Bradley (Ex-President of the Business Council of Australia and a career company director) recommended: first, resize the public service, and get rid of duplication with state governments in planning, education, environmental approvals and licensing generally. He says means test the NDIS and childcare subsidies, as well as reduce the subsidies for the energy transition goal. Bradley says mega-projects need to be independently reviewed, and the time targets should be realistic, so they don’t drive up costs. He also argues that the debt funding for big projects should be more transparent and not buried off the Government’s balance sheet or budget.

Bran Black: The BCA’s current CEO says stop subsidising people who don’t need help, meaning the fuel excise cuts and electricity rebates should be means tested.

Now this is not just a CEO bashing of a Treasurer from the other side of the political fence, because even as The Australian reports: “On Sunday, Reserve Bank chief economist Sarah Hunter said government spending was part of Australia’s inflation problem.”

AMP chief economist Shane Oliver has argued: “It’s not about just slowing the rate of growth, the level needs to come down too to take pressure off demand and allow faster productivity growth.”

Right now, government spending as a percentage of GDP this month hit 26.9%, the highest in 40 years outside the Covid pandemic.

Tomorrow, we see the latest CPI for the September quarter and if the inflation number is bad we could see a rate hike on Cup Day.

Next week, a full set of figures for the public service will be released by the Australian Bureau of Statistics. The last snapshot showed “there were 2.6 million public sector employee jobs [and] the federal public sector’s wage and salary bill jumped by 9.5 per cent, hitting more than $40bn for the first time. Total public sector cash wages and salaries increased 7.6 per cent to $249.5 billion.”

This public service spend has pumped up demand for the economy and added to inflation, but it really helped Labor accumulate votes at the last election, which, with 94 seats won out of 150, was the biggest win ever by a single party!

The price of that win was higher inflation, interest rates and a Treasurer asking for help to do a job he’s paid to do. Well, at least he’s starting to get help from people he should’ve been talking to ages ago!

Peter Switzer

Peter Switzer

Peter Switzer is the founder of Switzer Group - a content, publishing and financial services firm. Peter is an award-winning broadcaster, talking each morning to 2GB's Ben Fordham about the latest in finance and money. You can read his views daily on Switzer.com.au, and subscribe to Switzer Report for his latest insights, analysis and recommendations.

View all articles by Peter Switzer →

More from Peter Switzer

12 comments on “Chalmers asked where he should cut spending, and Australia’s top CEOs told him!”

  1. Roger W

    Jim needs to get out of the echo chamber.

    The upside is that his Leadership ambitions are shot to pieces.

    The electorate will not believe or trust him and would not tolerate him as a potential PM.

    Its over for Jim.

    Reply
  2. Todd S

    But it’s not like Jim will listen or actually do anything any business leader suggests.

    Labor *party* runs the government, not the politicians. If the *party* doesn’t, the bureaucrats do.

    It’s about time there were time limits on executive level bureaucrats, not just in the role, but time in the bureaucracy. 5 years max, and not just move to a new role in a different department. Must have a non-government past, and a non-government future.

    Lobbyists also need to be barred, along with Unions. This just breeds corruption and undue influence that doesn’t have the general populations interests at heart.

    Reply
  3. Stephen smith

    Totally agree with Roger’s comments

    However the whole government needs to go

    How come we always end in a mess when Labor are in charge of the purse strings.?

    For that matter, even the Liberals and their panicked funding during the COVID years has also contributed to the mess we are in

    😡

    Reply
    1. Kevin Cuyler

      The old Labor AND Liberal parties have long been compromised and no longer exist ……… they BOTH need to get off the roundabout. It’s been a Labor/Liberal Roundabout for decades with very little to separate them.

      Reply
  4. Harry Volting

    It really is breathtaking that the man in charge of our money doesn’t know how to identify spending cuts and live within his means. If he runs his household budget the same way, I’m surprised he is not homeless.

    His answer to everything is to seek out more areas to squeeze the lemon and collect more from those savers and real wealth creators. Punishing initiative and thrift is a recipe for disaster and creates more people in line for a handout!

    Astounding!

    Reply
  5. Peter

    I’d love to see the Treasurer and PM front a forum made up of elite economists and Leading CEOs asking the questions that need to be asked.
    Too often we see mainstream media journos going soft on the government and only interested in gotcha questions of anyone they don’t favour.
    Or the PM and Treasurer are controlling the narrative and picking the journos to ask brief questions. Remember the “50 times answer” at news conferences where we don’t get to the substance of the many issues raised in these articles.

    Reply
  6. Kevin Cuyler

    Jim will do as he’s told by the Fabians in charge. Albo and his Economic Vandals will continue on their road to destruction despite all the evidence. There are no economic principles and guidelines here ……. only idealists, hell bent on building their fantasy world.

    Reply
  7. Michael Lee

    Agree. Agree. Agree and stop sending Billions of dollars overseas (in an effort to curry favour for future International jobs) when we have extraordinary cost of living issues, unemployment, high unnecessary interest rates and Australians homeless.

    Reply
  8. Stephen smith

    Great comments herein Peter.

    We are all in the same page

    Cheers 🥂

    Reply
  9. Mal

    I think much of the money gifted to the Pacific Islands is about hoping to keep China at bay.
    The public sector has inherently been less productive than the private sector. The fact that you can fail in the public sector and be wildly over budget seems to mean let’s put more people on until we get it right.
    One thing I would add, is to stop trying to steal from Bob to try to boost Bill because very soon Bill also gets affected, which in turn, leads to an economic downturn overall which affects both Bob and Bill.

    Reply
  10. Julie

    It is unfortunate that we (the people and the mortgage holders) need to wear another rate hike on Melbourne Cup Day or early next year due to Government mismanaging our money.

    Reply
  11. John

    Jim chalmers seriously couldn’t manage the School tuck shop petty cash tin.
    He should downsize the public service for a start. What are the extra 30,000 public servants all doing? I have not noticed any significant improvement in service delivery.
    The scope of the NDIS should not have been allowed to grow to some unmanageable size well above what was envisaged. It was designed for the significantly handicapped. In addition the rorting is costing billions by service providers.
    Many programs like child minding services should be means tested. Why some one on a combined income of $500 thousand needs government handouts defies logic.
    Government foreign aid to the Taliban and other very suspect states should be stopped.
    The axe should be taken to subsidise for climate change projects. If they are that good let them stand on their own feet.
    I could go on and on but this hopeless government does not get it. The answer is not to throw money at every problem.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *