WiseTech and Xero shares are both down more than 40% this year. On this week’s Switzer Show, a market analyst and a fund manager made the case for both, and one has already been adding.
After a bruising year in the headlines, WiseTech Global closed at $38.64 on Tuesday 20 October, 72% below its record closing high of $138.93 on 21 November 2024. Xero, ever-defiant about AI, closed at $61.34, 68% below its record close of $194.21 on 24 June 2025.
Both are down more than 40% since the end of 2025: WiseTech by 43.6% and Xero by 46.2%. They aren’t alone, though. Over the past 12 months, the S&P/ASX 200 Information Technology index has fallen 40.6%. Both, however, are former darlings of said index and continue to attract investor scrutiny.
Host Peter Switzer put both stocks to Grady Wulff, Senior Market Analyst at Bell Direct, and Michael Wayne, Managing Director of Medallion Financial.
Time to move on from WiseTech?
Politely, WiseTech has been subject to more than a few governance issues in recent years. Most recently, on 15 October, WiseTech told the ASX that ASIC had concluded its investigation into alleged trading in WiseTech shares in respect of founder Richard White and two other current employees, and had issued them no-action letters. ASIC also issued the company a no-action letter on a separate governance investigation that began in late 2024. WiseTech said ASIC’s investigation is continuing in respect of one other person, who is not an employee.
Wulff said these so-called governance issues are behind the company. “Corporate governance issues are definitely in the past now. They’ve been factored into the share price,” she said. “It’s time to move on. The company is fantastic and they continue to go from strength to strength.”
She called it “a very sticky business” and said that when competitors appear, “[WiseTech] goes and snaps them up in acquisitions”, pointing to its purchase of e2open, which WiseTech valued at an enterprise value of US$2.1 billion.
In its 2026 annual report, WiseTech reported operating cash flow up 29% to US$564.0 million in FY26, with operating cash flow conversion of 101%.
Wayne’s fund, Medallion, held WiseTech through the fall, and isn’t planning on moving on. “We’ve been doubling down,” he said.
He said the stock is at “peak negativity, peak negative news”, and that there is “a very good business in and amongst all of the headlines”.
“It’s trading on 25 times earnings, maybe even slightly less, which is less than CBA, despite the fact it’s growing … significantly faster than the banks,” he said. “This is one that has formed the base and had a bit of a recovery despite some of the broader headwinds in tech globally.”
On the ASX’s figures, which use each company’s last reported statutory earnings per share, WiseTech trades on about 50 times earnings and CBA on about 24 times. Wayne did not say which earnings measure he was using.
Xero’s ‘next catalyst’
Xero reports its half-year results on 12 November. “That’s the next catalyst for us,” Wulff said.
She said that if Xero had stayed in cloud accounting alone, “[its] moat was going to become quickly redundant”, and that it has moved into payments through its acquisition of US bill-pay business Melio. “We’re really bullish on that outlook, but we want to see it flow through to material upgrades in earnings potential and revenue growth,” she said.
Wulff said she will be watching US revenue growth, Melio’s performance, subscriber growth in Australia, New Zealand and the UK, operating margins and free cash flow. She will also be watching progress towards Xero’s target for Melio to reach adjusted EBITDA break-even on a run-rate basis in the second half of FY28.
“A lot of the brokers are really bullish on it,” she said. “Hopefully they don’t get slammed too much more in this tech sell-off we’re seeing right now.”
Wayne’s fund has bought back in. “We are recently back in the [Xero] camp. We got out last year,” he said. “We just decided there were better alternatives elsewhere.”
He said investors have long criticised Xero for chasing revenue growth over earnings and free cash flow, and for struggling in the US. “However, the signs are that the US expansion is really going to plan. It’s really accelerating over there,” he said, although it is “highly unlikely to ever be the number one game in town compared to Intuit”.
He said many people see Xero as a software company “someone’s just going to sit in their garage and replicate”. He said “someone could probably replicate what Xero does in terms of a platform”, but not “all the embedded relationships, historical data that they’ve got”.
“If you think about Xero as a data company, all the small business information they’ve collected over the years” is significant, he said.
“It’s on track to get back into that rule of 40,” he said. The rule of 40 is a test for software companies: revenue growth plus free cash flow margin should add up to at least 40%.
“Although it hasn’t had this enormous recovery, it has found a pretty solid base.”
The Friday bounce
Peter noted that both stocks rose on Friday 16 October. WiseTech closed up 9.0% and Xero 7.1%. Both have kept that momentum into the new week.
Wayne put days like that down to “a bit of a rotation happening” at the margins, where some investors feel “maybe for a day or two that AI is expensive” and look at beaten-up software companies instead. “It doesn’t necessarily mean that all these software companies go back to their all-time highs,” he said.
Watch Grady Wulff and Michael Wayne on the full episode of the Switzer Show.
This article does not take into account the investment objectives, financial situation or particular needs of any individual. It does not constitute formal advice. Consider the appropriateness of the information in regards to your circumstances. Before acting on anything we discuss, we strongly recommend you seek the appropriate professional advice.
