Home › Feature Daily › A Cup Day rate rise? Jim and Michele should be scratched

A Cup Day rate rise? Jim and Michele should be scratched

The race that stops the nation could end with a rate rise that floors it. Before borrowers pay for Canberra’s mistakes yet again, it’s worth checking the form of the two people who got us here.

If you have a mortgage, you better start doing the form for the Melbourne Cup on Tuesday because all four big bank economics teams are tipping the Reserve Bank will be raising the cash rate by 0.25%. And given the hopeless performance of the Treasurer and the RBA Governor to do their jobs, it’s lucky we don’t do to them what used to happen to horses that couldn’t perform.

For those wondering, I’m thinking about the glue factory and the old Jane Fonda movie titled They Shoot Horses, Don’t They? but I’m only suggesting these analogies for comic effect. Let’s be more moderate here. A public flogging would be more appropriate come next election day.

Free Daily Newsletter

Never miss an expert insight

Join over 100,000 Australians who get Peter Switzer’s top finance stories delivered free every weekday.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

In case you missed it, the 12-month headline inflation went from 4% in August to 4.3% in September but the actual rise month on month was 0.8%, which is really big but the main drivers were housing costs and transport, with anyone driving a diesel-using car knowing how the Middle East war is hurting the hip pocket.

The quarterly trimmed mean inflation, which takes out volatile temporary factors hitting inflation, rose from 3.5 to 3.6%. As economist My Bui from AMP pointed out, this inflation measure is seen as “the gold standard as it has a long track record” so the reading is only 0.6% outside the 2-3% band desired by the RBA. Keep that thought as I’ll return to it.

Right now, the shoddy work of Jim Chalmers and Michele Bullock has resulted in:

  • 6.8 million Australian households knowing that their home is probably around 10% less valuable.
  • Mortgagees have seen a 1% increase in interest rates and for someone with a million-dollar loan, repayments have gone up by $150 per 0.25% rate hike, which means a $600 slug, thanks to these failed policy plays by Jim and Michele.
  • In the US there has been one rate rise. The UK has had zero rises!
  • US unemployment has gone from 4.1% to 4.2% while ours has risen from 4.1% to a five-year high of 4.7%. In the UK the jobless rate has fallen by 0.5%!
  • Insolvencies are 75% higher than the number before Covid.

The chart below shows how both fiscal and monetary policy have hurt business.

The failure of public policy is now being seen in the layoffs that are starting to be reported in the headlines. NAB is losing 2,500 employees (or 6% of its workforce) and this is only the start of a trend that will get worse as the RBA raises rates on Cup Day.

Economists at our banks make guesses on what they think the RBA will do and over the past week Deputy Governor Andrew Hauser and Assistant Governor and chief economist Sarah Hunter have hinted strongly that inflation was too high and so rate rises are likely.

Westpac’s chief economist, Luci Ellis, who was a one-time candidate for the job Michele Bullock got, thinks this Cup Day cash rate rise from 4.6 to 4.85% will be the last, but Luci and her rivals at the other big banks thought rate rises were over a few months back!

Given the economic wrecking ball rate rises are for mortgagees and small business and given the main drivers of the recent rise in inflation have been housing costs and petrol prices, you have to wonder how hitting borrowers will stop these cost-push factors on inflation.

It begs the question: is 3.6% trimmed inflation all that bad when the band is 2-3%? And why couldn’t we accept slightly higher inflation for a year or two if it is being caused by a Middle East and Ukraine war?

Of course, the inflation comes from government spending as well but why should borrowers be punished because Jim Chalmers and state treasurers have spent big on infrastructure outlays and vote-buying, like the Albanese Government’s 20% discount on HECS debt?

I believe that the RBA has done enough to bring down inflation by hitting borrowers with four rate rises, but it has been the work of Jim Chalmers, Donald Trump, the Iran leadership, Vladimir Putin and those in Australia that explain why our national productivity is the worst it has been since records began in 1960.

As the RBA has noted: “While Australia experienced an era of world-beating, robust productivity growth from the mid-1990s to the mid-2000s driven by sweeping economic reforms, that engine has stalled. In the past ten years, productivity grew by less than a quarter of its 60-year historic average.”

Not happy Jim and Michele. Not happy!

Clearly, Jim is the guy who has the most to explain but Michele needed to be tougher on him in public, and her three rate cuts in 2025 (an election year) will never look great on her CV.

Peter Switzer

Peter Switzer

Peter Switzer is the founder of Switzer Group - a content, publishing and financial services firm. Peter is an award-winning broadcaster, talking each morning to 2GB's Ben Fordham about the latest in finance and money. You can read his views daily on Switzer.com.au, and subscribe to Switzer Report for his latest insights, analysis and recommendations.

View all articles by Peter Switzer →

More from Peter Switzer

4 comments on “A Cup Day rate rise? Jim and Michele should be scratched”

  1. Harry Volting

    We can all see the damage ultra low interest rates have caused. Asset bubbles always burst, and the day of swift deflation has finally arrived. Reality and sensible pricing of money is always hard to swallow for those sucked in by assurances that rates won’t rise for years (remember that shocker).

    This is the shake up we had to have and maybe, just maybe, it will encourage saving and a thrifty approach to achieve large deposits before the tattooed and lip enhanced one’s embark on their instagrammable journey into home ownership.

    Of course, the government’s wasteful ways don’t help in keeping things under control. They are also addicted to the live for the day mentality that is rampant in society.

    Reply
  2. Stephen smith

    Admit it Pete. You had it wrong.

    Warren Hogan (Rabo Bank) cited this would happen over two years ago

    And unfortunately it is going to get a lot worse for Aussie battlers.

    I agree that Grim Jim and RBA governor Bullock are partially to blame. Bullock should have gone harder on rate increases much earlier when Hogan called for it instead of being ambushed to lower the rate by the Chalmer.

    Chalmers never had it in him to lower government spending.

    This stupid strategy to clobber business with more taxes to plug a budget hole will not work in the end. Remember what Margy Thatcher said about Socialism back in the 70s.

    You spoke against a strategy to increase rates back then. Now we have even a bigger mess than before.

    That “R” word looking more likely each day

    😢

    Reply
  3. Harry Volting

    And one more thing. Who says the narrow target range of 2-3% is right? Maybe, in this day of so many moving objects that impact inflation, the range needs to be a little broader, say 1.5% – 4%. Provided unemployment doesn’t go through the roof and per capita productivity increases, wouldn’t this be a more sensible approach?

    Reply
  4. RICHARD ASHTON

    It is difficult to work out the more incompetent, clueless and inept ..Ms Bulloock or “Dr” Chalmers .
    Who pays for this ? …the Australian public they are ( massively ) paid to “guide.”

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *