1 April 2020
1300 794 893
Why ScoMo isn't just the last man standing.

Is Morrison a Bradbury PM?

Peter Switzer
19 September 2018

If you want to work out why leading a political party is so hard nowadays just look at what Scott Morrison has had to deal with just last week. And given what I will recap on, you have to wonder if someone who has been described as a Bradbury PM — being nearly the last man standing — will be able to rebuild his party enough for them to be a chance at the next election.

Before looking at the fairness of the Bradbury tag, which personally I think is fair, let’s have a look at what Scott has had to cop last week.

Here goes:

  • Malcolm Turnbull is campaigning out of New York to expose Peter Dutton as someone who should not be in Parliament because his wife’s childcare business received Government funding!
  • Ex-Deputy PM, Julie Bishop has not ruled out voting that Peter Dutton face the High Court on the matter if Labor brings on a vote to send PD — an ex-cop — to the highest court in the land!
  • Scott wanted a female replacement for Malcolm in the upcoming seat of Wentworth by-election because of Malcolm’s exit and he got David Sharma, so his ‘followers’ in the seat did not follow his directions!
  • He tweeted a video of Question Time, which was supposed to paint a picture of unity but the song used was politically incorrect and so the new PM had to tweet out another apologetic tweet.
  • And the week started with Newspoll telling us that he is the preferred Prime Minister over Bill Shorten but unfortunately the same people who think this also think his Government/party stinks!

The Coalition is behind Labor by 44 to 56 on a two-party preferred vote and this is Labor's strongest primary vote since the party gave Kevin Rudd the heave-ho as Prime Minister in July 2010. Seriously, as someone who has known Scott since UNSW days when I taught him Macroeconomics 101, he doesn’t need another hair-losing week like this.

Looking at these roadblocks to success, which this mob have been great at building for themselves, you can understand why Malcolm is trying to get even with the party that rejected him. It might not be right but I know why he’s doing it — he’s pissed off and he’s not really a politician — and that’s why he lost the gig as the country’s leader.

Julie too would be cheesed off and PD better be in the clear or he’ll be seen as a dope of Barnaby proportions!

Wentworth’s decision shows what is wrong with the Libs — they don’t do as they’re told, as they would have under John Howard post-1996 and under Bob Menzies before that.

On the video mistake, a young person in the Fairfax press gallery journo, Latika Bourke, has raised PC eyes over the choice of a song that has sleazy, rap lyrics. But I can bet you Scott wouldn’t have heard the song before some flunky team member came up with a ‘great idea’ to add music and have Scott leading a unified Government putting their hands up to some rap crap about dollar bills!

Seriously, Latika, people not regarded as young don’t listen to music like this and when we’re forced to endure it we can hardly make out the lyrics! I can remember in my 30’s using MC Hammer’s “don’t touch this” lyrics in a news report but to this day I couldn’t tell you what “this” is and frankly, I don’t want to know!

The lesson for Scott has to be to become like micromanaging entrepreneurs, who don’t trust anyone with their precious brand! And this goes double for young and groovy members of staff who thought this video rap crap was a vote-winner.

And now to the Bradbury comparison, which I used in a speech this week. Unlike the uninformed, I think Steven Bradbury is a classic Aussie, whose gold medal via some luck was an overdue reward for a champ!

I interviewed Steven when I did the Qantas inflight program, Talking Business, for a decade. That’s when I learnt that he wasn’t just a lucky guy, who saw his four opponents fall over. No, he was a guy who was good enough to be in the final of an Olympics with the some of the best skaters of all time. And at his fourth Olympics, he won the gold he probably could have won at previous Olympics, if he hadn’t had bad luck. 

Bradbury’s record

  • A lot of people think he was just a jerk from Australia who ended up with a gold medal, so let me sum up his record. Here goes:
  • 1991 member of gold medal relay team over 5000 metres to win the World Championships.
  • 1994 member of the team that took bronze in the relay in Norway.
  • 1994 was favourite to take gold in the 1000 metre sprint but was knocked out by a rival in the semi-final and limped home in fourth place.
  • In 2000, he broke his neck.
  • In 2002, he won his first heat of the 1000 metres event. And then took the final when the other four skaters fell. And, in doing so, Australia won its first gold medal at a Winter Olympics.
  • He had been a world-class skater for over a decade, including being number one rated skater in the world at one time. He was a man whose time had come!

Morrison’s record

Interestingly, Scott’s record as Treasury has been on show over the past couple of weeks, with economic growth coming in at 3.4% for the year to the June quarter and 3% for the year to the March quarter, which many economists predicted wouldn’t happen! Meanwhile, in the year to January this is what CommSec’s Craig James had to say about the then latest jobs report: “Records are made to be broken. Employment has risen for a record 16th straight month, moving ahead of the previous record period of job gains from May 1993 to July 1994. Over the past year, 403,300 jobs have been created – the most jobs in 12½ years.”

And for the year to date, after 44,000 jobs showed up in August, some 176,000 jobs have been created and many economists doubted that would happen at the beginning of the year too

During Morrison’s time as Treasurer, the NAB’s business conditions readings hit an all-time high in April this year. Consumer confidence has trended up into positive territory and the consumer is starting to spend again, if we can trust last week’s growth numbers.

And because there have been so many jobs created, tax collections are rising and spending on the unemployed is falling, and so is the Budget Deficit. The last progressive reading was that it was down to around $12 billion, but if these jobs keep being created we could see a balanced, or even surplus, Budget way before anyone expected!

Good Treasurers have often ended up as PMs and ScoMo, like Bradbury, had it coming to him.

But being PM is harder than being a Treasurer so he better learn about being a Prime Ministerial leader ASAP. And I’d be getting my skates on as fast as possible to find a coach who resembles someone like John Howard.

And history shows that JH was the last man standing when he got the top Lib gig in 1995, after years of trying and failing to convince his party he was a gold medal leader. And he went on to become the second longest serving PM in Australian history!

Go Aussie Bradburys!

Click here to sign up for a free 21-day trial to the Switzer Report.

Let us know what you think
Get the latest financial, business, and political expert commentary delivered to your inbox.

When you sign up, we will never give away or sell or barter or trade your email address.

And you can unsubscribe at any time!
1300 794 893
© 2006-2019 Switzer. All Rights Reserved
homephoneenvelopedollargraduation-cap linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram