4 April 2020
1300 794 893

Gimme some truth

Peter Switzer
2 October 2018

When it comes to the Aussie economy, it seems as though the penny has well and truly dropped that business promoters can use the economy to gain attention for their operations. Many tend to do this by trying to scare the pants off people. We saw this happen in that 60 Minutes programme that had people asking me about a 40% fall in house prices!

And recently, a business did a survey and came up with predictions about what the fall in house prices will be in specific suburbs. One media outlet lapped that up and then other media outlets picked up on it. The crafty business that started it all had created the media marketing momentum it was looking for — but did it give us a true story?

Economic accuracy, or the pursuit of it, is running a long second to the first goal of businesses or people trying to get media cut through. The cumulative damage is piled on to the impressions of consumers and small business owners about how economy is faring.

Imagine if the wrong impression is being created by over-hyping — it could really hurt the economic growth and job creation ability of the economy. This could force up the Budget Deficit, just when it is falling to $10 billion, when it was predicted to be $29 billion only a year ago!

I hope you see my point — the economy could be a casualty, as business-builders seek publicity via making scary predictions about the economy.

So, with inspiration from John Lennon, l hope you are thinking: “Gimme some truth!”

On house prices, few respected economists think we face house price Armageddon, with NAB’s Alan Oster telling the Your Money channel that only if unemployment topped 8% would he expect big house price falls. Yesterday we learnt that Sydney house prices are down 6.1% over the past year, while Melbourne has given up 3.4%.

Similar or slightly bigger falls over the next 12 months are likely but it could be made worse if the punishment for the banks from the Royal Commission means getting a loan becomes tougher. This is a threat to the economy, which is hard to read but I do know groups (such as the non-bank lenders La Trobe Financial and Pepper Money) are starting to fill the gap. However, if the gap gets too big, the economy could slow down.

Only on Friday we saw that loans and advances by non-bank financial intermediaries rose by 10.3% over the year to August, up from 6.2% in July and the strongest annual growth in a decade!

Let me give you the run of recent economic data and you make up your mind whether Alan Oster’s belief that unemployment is more likely to fall from the current level of 5.3% to around 5%, rather than the 8% unemployment levels implied by house price “prophets of doom”.

Here goes:

• Private sector credit (loans) rose by 0.5% in August, after a 0.4% rise in July. Credit was up 4.5% over the year, up from the 4½-year low of 4.4% in July.

• Job vacancies rose by 0.6% to a record 238,200 in the three months to August. Job vacancies are up by 16.5% on a year ago – easing from the strongest annual growth rate in 7½ years.

• Foreigners like our prospects holding a record $604.9 billion of Aussie shares in the June quarter, up from $563.6 billion in the March quarter.

•  Engineering work done for the public sector rose by 2.7% in the June quarter. Over the year to June, a record $37.4 billion of work was done for the public sector.

• Excluding resources, engineering work yet to be done stands at $43.1 billion, below record highs. But outstanding road and railway work were both just below record highs. And electricity generation, transmission and distribution work was at five-year highs.

• The budget deficit for 2017/18 was $10.1 billion, or 0.6% of GDP. The budget deficit was an $8.1 billion improvement on the $18.2 billion deficit forecast just four months ago and compares with the $29.4 billion deficit projection at the time of the May 2017 budget.

• The ANZ-Roy Morgan estimate of family finances compared with a year ago stands at 8-month highs.

• Australia’s population expanded by 380,722 people over the year to March 2018 to 24,899,077. Recently the RBA boss, Phil Lowe, explained the importance of people with “Australia's faster population growth [is] one of the reasons our economy has experienced higher average growth than many other advanced economies…”

• With unemployment steady at 5.3%, employment rose by 44,000 in August. Full-time jobs rose by 33,700 and part-time jobs rose by 10,200. Economists had tipped an increase in total jobs of around 18,000.

• In trend terms, the unemployment rate for 15-24 year olds hit a 7-year low of 11.2%. The jobless rate for 15-19 year olds was at a 5-year low of 16.2%.

• The average credit card balance fell by $54.60 to $3,223.70 in July, down from five-year highs of $3,278.30 in June. But balances were up by 5% over the year – the strongest annual growth rate in a decade. This is a plus sign for consumer spending.

• The Westpac/Melbourne Institute survey of consumer sentiment index fell by 3% to 100.5 in September – the lowest level in 10 months. The index is below its long-term average of 101.5. A reading above 100 denotes optimism but this was taken after the leadership coup and could prove dodgy.

• In the latest quarterly survey from Westpac and the Melbourne Institute, 7.2% of respondents thought the ‘wisest use of savings’ was to ‘spend it’ – the second highest survey response in seven years. 

• The NAB business confidence index eased from +7.0 points in July to a 25-month low of +4.4 points in August. The long-term average is +6 points. 

• The NAB business conditions index rose from +12.6 points in July to a 4-month high of +15.2 points in August. The long-term average is +5.7 points.

• The Performance of Construction index (PCI) eased to 51.8 in August from 52 in July. The index has been above 50 for 19 straight months, indicating expansion in the construction sector. Engineering activity has expanded for 17 consecutive months.

• The proportion of first homebuyers in the market remained near six-year highs.

• The AiGroup services sector gauge eased 1.4 points to 52.2 in August. Services activity has now expanded for 18 consecutive months - the equal longest stretch since March 2008. 

• The Performance of Construction index (PCI) eased to 51.8 in August from 52 in July. The index has been above 50 for 19 straight months, indicating expansion in the construction sector. Engineering activity has expanded for 17 consecutive months.

The apartments PCI sub-index fell from 36.7 in July to 32.8 in August – the lowest level in nearly six years. Activity in the apartment sector has contracted for six successive months.

I could go on with largely positive takes on our economy but I think I’ve made a pretty truthful case about how damn good our economy is right now.

Sure, there are threats out there, with petrol prices at four-year highs, but interest rates are at historic lows. House price falls are a negative but the threat of unsubstantiated big falls is the biggest worry. Trump and trade wars with China are other concerns but the impact of these things is hard to calculate.

Remaining positive on the Oz economy is the more logical stance to have — and that’s the truth.

Click here to sign up for a free 21-day trial to the Switzer Report.

Let us know what you think
Get the latest financial, business, and political expert commentary delivered to your inbox.

When you sign up, we will never give away or sell or barter or trade your email address.

And you can unsubscribe at any time!
1300 794 893
© 2006-2019 Switzer. All Rights Reserved
homephoneenvelopedollargraduation-cap linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram