When it comes to some journalists and media outlets, who thrive off creating scary headlines that even I’m silly enough to click on to, I do often think: “Forgive them Lord for they know not what they do.”
My basic proposition is that my mates in the media, in their eternal search for relevance, ignore the old song of Johnny Mercer and the Pied Pipers. In case you’ve missed it, the lyrics go:
Man, they said we better, accentuate the positive
Eliminate the negative
Latch on to the affirmative
Don't mess with Mister In-Between …
Quite frankly, given the media’s preoccupation with accentuating the negative and eliminating the positive, I’d cop Mr. In-Between!
I often rail about struggling media outlets and their employees, which rely on advertising, creating false headlines that undermine confidence and actually contribute to an economic downturn that could hurt the businesses that spend money with the media operations.
This, in turn, could kill the jobs of the people who are accessories before the fact!
Don’t get me wrong. If we’re heading for a recession, I’ll be trying to be the first to inform my readers, Switzer Super Report subscribers, listeners to my radio show and viewers of my TV program. However, I won’t play negative, confidence-crushing games with headlines to attract readers.
I fell into a housing collapse story for Australia when the US business website, CNBC, ran with the headline: “Australian housing market at risk of crash, according to UBS research.”
It turned out to be an old story from last week and even though UBS is a Swiss Bank, the research was done locally.
According to the UBS economist, George Tharenou, who put the yarn together, the story really is: "We still see a correction, but not a collapse, but if the RBA hikes too early or too much (as flagged by its hawkish minutes), it risks triggering a crash".
My (maybe naïve) question is: why isn't the headline “UBS doesn’t see house price collapse?” Or maybe: “RBA to raise rates slowly to avoid housing collapse”.
The risk is the Reserve Bank and I’d trust the bank not to screw up the rate rises, given it’s been stressing out about housing for two to three years.
I know this and so do experts in the money industry. However real people, who contribute to overall consumer sentiment, retail spending, economic growth and inevitably job creation might not. Therefore, media outlets scaring people for click bait reasons, need to think about the ramifications of their actions.
As John Lennon implored: “Gimme some truth” which is a pretty good idea, if the media remembers the importance of trying to print what’s real rather than what scares.
On Thursday, after Wednesday’s important inflation data, I’ll give you some economic truth on how the Oz economy is really going.
By the way, last night on my Sky News Business program, I interviewed Tim Lawless, the research director of real estate stats business Core Logic.
He noted how incomes had not kept up with the rapid rise in house prices in Sydney and Melbourne. That’s a worry and it’s why the RBA shouldn’t rush to raise rates too soon or too quickly, as the UBS economist also observed.
However, Tim did say in Melbourne that house price rises now are more in the outer rings of the city, where prices are relatively lower. Meanwhile, in Sydney, the outer rings of the West are seeing house price growth slowdowns but in the cool, inner city suburbs, the price action remains pretty hot.
The rest of the country is not a ‘house price growth’ worry.
The bottom line is that provided the Oz economy grows well, as the RBA expects, and interest rates only rise slowly, then house prices will come off the boil and not collapse.
By the way, this is what most sensible economists expect to happen.
As UBS’s George Tharenou put it: “We still see rates on hold in the coming year, amid macro-prudential tightening on credit growth and interest only loans. Hence we still see a correction, but not a collapse…”
If you liked this article you'll love the Switzer Report, our newsletter and website for trustees of self-managed super funds. Click here for a FREE trial and to hear more of Peter’s expert commentary and advice.