9 April 2020
1300 794 893

Could apartment oversupply KO banks and the economy?

Peter Switzer
17 October 2016

By Peter Switzer

I’m off to Thailand today for a hit-and-run speech for an Australian business conference, so what will I tell them about our economy? It comes as two really smart market players think there’s a big bond curve ball ready to hit markets between the eyes.

Meanwhile, alarmist doomsday merchants are feeding the media about all manner of problems, with the latest linking an apartment oversupply to a bank balance sheet problem. A few weeks back, it was apartments causing a recession but all my really smart economics experts put that as a really lower order risk.

Over the weekend, The Australian looked at Reserve Bank concerns over apartment oversupply over the next two years that could hurt our banks. The key word is “could” and to what extent is anyone’s guess.

In case you missed it, The Oz’s David Uren wrote: “The Reserve Bank has warned that the massive number of new apartment blocks approaching completion could send some of their developers broke and leave the banks nursing big losses.”

They think some 40,000 apartments will be completed and falling prices and finance access problems could lead to defaults and bank problems!

But David did add this: “There are signs that some settlements are taking longer and lending valuations are coming in below their contract price, though settlement failures to date remain low,” the bank said. (I put the bold type in to make the point that failures remain low.)

The real estate industry is not too stressed about it all but it’s in their interest not to add to any negativity.

And David did add this, which kept me cautiously positive: “It [the RBA] has modeled the effect on the banks if between 5 and 15 per cent of the contracted buyers of apartments defaulted. However, it found that bank losses would remain low, at less than $200m, provided apartment prices did not fall by more than 25 per cent!” (I added the exclamation mark!)

Those losses are like lunch money to our big four banks, so let’s look at what I’m going to say about our economy now.

Here goes:

  • Business confidence: rose from +5.6 points to +5.9 points and the long-term average is +5.8.
  • Business conditions: rose from +6.8 points to 7.7 points in June and the long-term average is +4.8 points.
  • Consumer confidence: The Westpac/Melbourne Institute survey of consumer sentiment rose by 1.1% in October to 102.4. The confidence index is up 4.7% on a year ago. The survey was conducted between October 3 and October 6.
  • The March economic growth number was 1.1%, taking annual growth to 3.1%.
  • June quarter 3.3% — 100 quarters of no recession!
  • Growth is now the fastest in three and a half years.
  • Growth over 3% takes unemployment down.
  • Unemployment at 5.6% is around a two-and-a-half year low.
  • Job ads are up 3.7% over the year, so bosses seem positive.
  • The CBA’s look at economy-wide sales is at a six-year high.
  • Capital city home prices rose by 1% in September and are 7.1% higher over the year. Regional prices were only up 1.4% in year to August.
  • Total household wealth at a record $8,891.2 billion as at end of June 2016, up $231.5 billion or 2.7% over the quarter and CommSec estimates wealth rose $368,945 in the June quarter, up $8,895 over the quarter and a record!
  • Retail rose by 0.4% in August after rising by 0.1% in July. Retail trade is up 2.8% for year.
  • Takeaway food sales lifted 1.5% in August, to be up 11.4% on a year ago – the strongest annual growth in six years.
  • The Performance of Services index lifted 3.9 points to 48.9 points in September – the second consecutive month of contraction.
  • The Performance of Manufacturing index rose by 2.9 points to 49.8 in September. (The index was above 50 for 11 months – the longest period of expansion since September 2006!)
  • Over the past year, 238,204 new homes were approved, just shy of the record high 240,989 in the year to October 2015.
  • Inbound travellers - 1.833 million, up 11.1% over the year. 
  • Tourists from China and Hong Kong rose to a record 1,419,900 over the year to August, up 21.3% over the year.
  • New motor vehicle sales totaled 102,696 in September, up 1.3% on a year ago. A record 1,179,652 new vehicles were sold over the year to September.

As you can see, we’re living in a pretty damn good economy. And the RBA’s own forecasts for our economy goes from a top-of-the-range reading of 3%, which was pretty well spot on for June this year, to 4% by the end of next year!

Sure, we have to navigate China’s growth story (will it be lower than expected?), the US election and an expected interest rate rise, as well the usual annoyances from OPEC, Russia and Iran, along with bond market concerns and there is Japan as well as Europe, which have growth problems.

The smarty doomsday merchants one day will be right but I suspect they are jumping the gun. Note, even the RBA thought our bank problems, if they ever materialise, would be in two years’ time.

And have a look at this headline from Google to understand the unreliability of click bait:

 “Banks face challenge on billions of off-balance sheet exposure.” (SMH)

When did we see this? Try November 4, 2008 not long before our top four banks were listed in the top 10 in the world, thanks to the GFC!

The apartment oversupply will cause some losses but I’m not expecting Armageddon. And a lot of smart property/economic experts agree and based on the RBA’s growth forecasts, the Big Bank is not too spooked either.

As my favourite social commentator from yesteryear, Alfred E. Neuman would’ve said: “What, me worry?”.

Peter Switzer's book Join the Rich Club is on sale for 30% off from the Switzer Store until the end of Easter. Click here to pick up a copy today!

Let us know what you think
Get the latest financial, business, and political expert commentary delivered to your inbox.

When you sign up, we will never give away or sell or barter or trade your email address.

And you can unsubscribe at any time!
1300 794 893
© 2006-2019 Switzer. All Rights Reserved
homephoneenvelopedollargraduation-cap linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram